In the previous issue, we recommended the best mattresses of 2024. This time, we will continue to recommend several mattresses worth buying in 2024.
Best Mattress on Amazon
Tuft & Needle T&N Original Mattress
Pros
- Fast and free shipping
- Under $1,000
- Supportive foam with motion isolation
Cons
- Lacks edge support
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Shoppers who need a mattress delivered quickly (rather than waiting for a scheduled delivery service).
- Sleepers who prefer a firmer memory foam instead of one that’s more cushy and plush.
- Price-conscious buyers.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- People who need edge support when getting in and out of bed.
- Those who would prefer a taller mattress with more layers.
Best Mattress for Back Pain
Nolah Original 10”
Pros
- Testers swore it eased back pain
- High scores for comfort and support
- Users say it sleeps cooler than other foam models
Cons
- Low height may be cumbersome to those with mobility issues
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Sleepers struggling with pain, like hip pain, back pain, pregnancy-related pain and sciatica.
- Side sleepers; though it can be used for a range of sleep positions.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- People who prefer a taller mattress, especially for getting in and out of bed. This one is only 10-inches high, but Nolah’s Evolution 15-inch model is a taller, more expensive hybrid model that was also loved by our reviewers with back pain.
Best Memory Foam Mattress-in-a-Box
Casper Original Mattress
Pros
- Easy ordering and DIY set up
- Ergonomic support
- Users say it maintains its shape over time
Cons
- Casper will be phasing out this model eventually
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Sleepers who prefer the cradling comfort of memory foam.
- Those willing to spend a bit more for foam to get ergonomic support.
- Back and side sleepers because of the split zones for alignment.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- People over the age of 40, who may not find it as comfortable. It was more well-liked by our under-40 testers.
Best Soft Mattress
Puffy Lux Hybrid Mattress
Pros
- Plush with contouring support
- Users swear it improves sleep quality
- Our reviewers praised how well it has kept its shape
Cons
- Testers didn’t seem to notice the claimed cooling effect
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Side sleepers.
- Back pain sufferers.
- Anyone who prefers a cushiony feel for their mattress.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- People who prefer a firm mattress. Even though users describe it as supportive, it still has a plush feel.
Best Firm Mattress
Stearns & Foster Estate Mattress
Pros
- Unique innerspring coils for firm support
- Options to add a pillowtop or more memory foam layers
- High-quality and hand-crafted materials
Cons
- Over $2,000
- Less pressure relief
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Stomach sleepers.
- Heavier body weights.
- Anyone who prefers a firm mattress.
- In-store shoppers who want to feel it in person at their local mattress store.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- Side sleepers, especially those with lighter body weights because it can put too much pressure on the hips.
- Sleepers who prefer a plush mattress.
Best Cooling Mattress
Purple Mattress
Pros
- Testers consistently tell us it sleeps cool
- Elastic grid is squishy yet supportive
- Good pressure relief and motion isolation
Cons
- Some users experienced shipping delays
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Hot sleepers who get sweaty at night.
- Couples because of its motion isolation.
- Heavier body weights; it has a 600-pound capacity (or 300 pounds on each side).
- People who are tired of the same old mattress feel and want to try something unique.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- Those who prefer to use a mattress pad or mattress topper. You won’t feel the grid’s cooling effects if there is excess material getting in the way.
- Cold sleepers; some people find the gel grid cools them down too much.
- People who prefer a tall mattress.
Most Popular Mattress
Serta Perfect Sleeper Hybrid Mattress
Pros
- High praise for comfort and support from testers
- Available to try out in stores
- Great price for a hybrid model
Cons
- Some long-term Serta owners said the mattress felt less comfortable over time
WHO IT’S BEST FOR:
- Price-conscious buyers who want a luxury feel without spending over $1,000.
- Shoppers who prefer to feel their mattress in person before they buy. You can find Serta models at major mattress retailers.
WHO SHOULD AVOID IT:
- Those who prefer a mattress with more ‘bounce.’ This one sinks in more than an innerspring.
- Anyone who wants to invest more in a long-term mattress; there were some concerns around longevity in our surveys.
- People who get overwhelmed with too many options. There are five models within the Perfect Sleeper collection and each one has variations.
